SkyTrain Here, SkyTrain There, SkyTrain Everywhere, So Taxpayer’s Beware!

Well, Metro Vancouver’s mini-Trump and so called transit expert, Doug McCallum is back in office.

Yes, sir, he’s the guy who said he was an “expert” who killed the then planned Surrey LRT project and instead, claimed he could build SkyTrain to Langley for the same $1.65 billion cost. Funny that the full cost of the 16 km extension is now costing north of $8 billion!

So, SkyTrain loving Doug ran on the ticket to extend SkyTrain down the King George to Rootin Tootin Newton, famous for its strip bar back in the day.

The first question Zwei asks is the “cost?”

None of this back of the envelope stuff that BC politcans use but the real cost!

This would include 8 km of guideway (based on the Langley extension of $6 billion for 16 km or $375 million/km) ……….

~ that was the cost in 2024, before tariffs and inflation and in 2026, the cost is now past $396 million/km ~

………. but wait, this does not include signalling, the electrics and the the new junction on the Expo line and reinstalling of the Expo Line to accommodate the extra trains. This would entail the demolition of the guideway (closing the system past the new junction) of a lengthy period of time and installing new sections of guideway accommodating the switches need. This cost may add upwards of $300 million to the cost of the project.

Signalling will be another expensive item as the the recent $1.47 re-signalling program did not include a King George extension.

I do not know the cost, but I have been assured that it will be expensive.

Then there is the pesky question about cars because Alstom is going to cease production of the MK.5, Innovia 300 cars after the Vancouver order is completed , simply there is no market for them as the trains used on the Expo line are proprietary and there is no market for them.

Oh, the SkyTrain Lobby, will claim that the Chinese Railway Corporation (CRRC) produce compatible cars and yes, they do, but they are 35 year old cloned ART, Innovia 100 cars.

The CRRC does not recognize intellectual property (patents) and the cars they delivered to Kuala Lumpur were cloned from Beijing Airport’s ART (Advanced Rapid Transit was the name of the system when Bombardier sold the proprietary railway abroad.). So, yes the CRRC could supply cars, but cars that are basically 30 years out of date as they will not spend a penny updating them.

New cars with questionable patented technology may mire TransLink is very expensive, future legal issues and may find themselves with new cars that would be illegal to operate in Canada.

So back to the question of cost.

A conservative cost estimate for a 8km extension of SkyTrain to Rootin Tootin Newton would be a minimum of $3.5 billion

Funding?

Well, stand in line. BC can afford about one light metro project a decade and with two projects, now costing north of $18 billion (full cost), there will be little appetite from the provincial government to fund it as other transit projects also need major funding, including, Expo line extension to UBC, the E&N, BC Rail, North Shore to Metro Town SkyTrain, Massey tunnel replacement and more! Collectively there is a bare minimum $30 billion worth of politcal promises outstanding and a $3.5 billion SkyTrain Line to move, at best a maximum of 2,000 pphpd comes at the very end of the want table.

I would say there is zero chance of funding for this line, but as we all know……………..

SkyTrain is built in BC to win elections and not move people and the taxpayer as zero say in the matter. “You will get SkyTrain whether you like it or not”, is always the motto of the government of the day!


As a general observation, the SkyTrain Lobby is going full tilt promoting the dated, proprietary light metro system on YouTube and electronic media.

Most recently, YouTube foamer Reece Martin published a report saying SkyTrain is the number one transit system in Canada.

Really?

SkyTrain, the best transit system in Canada? That no one, in Canada or the world wants to buy, nor wanted to buy in the past twenty-five years!

Only 7 such systems were built in almost 50 years with only 6 remaining in operation with zero interest in the proprietary system in past quarter of a century. You call that the best transit system in Canada?

Think about that for a moment!

Leave A Comment